Analysis: Oscar's best-picture nominees

The Oscar nominations underscore a particularly strong year for Hollywood. USA TODAY's Scott Bowles examines the nine nominees for best picture and the challenges they face in pursuit of the granddaddy prize.

12 Years a Slave

• In its corner: Scope. The true story of a free New York man of color sold into slavery has the tenor and sweep that the academy loves.

• In its way: Disco. American Hustle, considered Slave's chief rival, has been upstaging the competition with strong acting performances and 1970s-drenched style.

American Hustle

• In its corner: Timing. David O. Russell's Abscam comedy has cleaned up in the early awards competitions. And for Oscars, timing is everything. Sunday's Golden Globewin is a big boost in its campaign.

• In its way: Tone. Hustle is the only comedy in the group and the academy is known to prefer serious fare.

Captain Phillips

• In its corner: Tom Hanks. Though he's not nominated for best actor, Hanks is considered royalty by the academy and his films can never be taken lightly.

• In its way: Gravity's shadow. Phillips opened a week after Gravity and has never gotten out from under the sci-fi saga's shadow (Gravity opened with $55.8 million,Phillips $25.7 million).

Dallas Buyers Club

• In its corner: Acting. The film might sweep the acting categories via knockout performances by lead Matthew McConaughey (a favorite with Nebraska's Dern) and supporting actor Jared Leto. Strong casts often make for best-picture winners.

• In its way: See above. DBC is being recognized mostly as an actors' showcase and has gotten little attention as a film overall,


• In its corner: Populism. It's the best reviewed and highest grossing film ($256 million domestically) in the Oscar race. As the academy proved with Titanic and Avatar, it loves juggernauts.

• In its way: Blowback. Even though it's a feature film, Gravity has taken some shots from the scientific community for inaccuracies. You never want to be on the wrong side of science in an Oscar race.


• In its corner: Quirkiness. No film touches Spike Jonze's romance between a man and a computer operating system. It's seen as the "unusual'' film of the race.

• In its way: Quirkiness. The academy is not known for taking chances and usually sides with classic subject matter.


• In its corner: Bruce Dern. Across the board this Hollywood icon is getting hailed as having turned in the best performance of his long career, and he was rewarded with a leading actor nomination.

• In its way: Lack of grandeur. Shot in black-and-white and with a small budget, Nebraska is seen as a two-person vehicle, with supporting actress nominee June Squibb holding her own with Dern. Outside of those two, the movie hasn't generated much notice in any category.


• In its corner: Dame Judi Dench. Aside from Meryl Streep, no actress is as beloved. Any of Dench's top movies should be considered a threat.

• In its way: Lack of popularity. No one besides critics and movie circles has seen this film, and moviegoers don't appear to be eager to catch the drama.

The Wolf of Wall Street

• In its corner: Pedigree. Martin Scorsese and Leonardo DiCaprio have become the most iconic director/actor duo since Scorsese and Robert DeNiro.

• In its way: Coarseness and length. The f-bombs, three-hour length and celebration of greed has some voters taken aback. And if anything the academy is known for its conservative traits.


To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the
Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Leave a Comment